The Super Bowl has seen its fair share of lopsided contests, especially during the 1980s. However, throughout its storied history, there have been numerous games that left fans on the edge of their seats. From remarkable comebacks and dramatic fourth quarters to unexpected upsets, these 15 Super Bowls stand out as the most thrilling of all time. Let's dive into the games that have captivated audiences and solidified the Super Bowl as the pinnacle of excitement in sports.
15. Super Bowl XXXII: Denver 31, Green Bay 24
John Elway’s Super Bowl redemption came against the heavily favored Packers. Terrell Davis’s 157 yards and three touchdowns earned him MVP honors. Elway’s memorable helicopter scramble and a back-and-forth battle culminated in Denver’s first Super Bowl victory, shaking off Elway’s “best quarterback to never win a Super Bowl” label.
The Broncos' determined play and the Packers' fierce competitiveness created an electrifying atmosphere, making this game unforgettable for fans. Elway’s perseverance and leadership in the face of previous Super Bowl disappointments made this victory particularly sweet for Denver. The game not only provided a thrilling finish but also cemented Elway’s legacy as one of the greats. His performance, along with Davis's dominance, showcased the resilience and determination needed to win on the grandest stage.
14. Super Bowl V: Baltimore 16, Dallas 13
In a game that seemed destined for overtime, Mike Curtis’s interception set up the Colts with excellent field position. Jim O’Brien’s 32-yard field goal with five seconds left clinched the win, making this one of the more dramatic finishes in Super Bowl history. Despite the game being marred by turnovers and mistakes, it’s remembered for its nail-biting conclusion.
Baltimore's ability to seize the moment in the final seconds and Dallas's inability to capitalize on earlier opportunities highlighted the unpredictable nature of football. This game, often referred to as the "Blunder Bowl," showed that even a game filled with errors could have an exhilarating and memorable conclusion. The Colts' persistence paid off in the end, marking a significant triumph in a chaotic, yet thrilling, Super Bowl.
13. Super Bowl LIV: Kansas City 31, San Francisco 20
Patrick Mahomes engineered a remarkable comeback after trailing 20-10 with just under nine minutes left. The Chiefs scored three touchdowns in the final minutes, turning a seemingly comfortable San Francisco lead into a thrilling Kansas City victory, capturing their first Super Bowl in 50 years. Mahomes’ leadership and the Chiefs' explosive offense were on full display as they dismantled the 49ers’ defense in the closing moments.
The game epitomized resilience and showcased why Mahomes is considered one of the brightest talents in the NFL. San Francisco's strong defensive performance for most of the game made the Chiefs' comeback even more impressive and highlighted the unpredictable and dynamic nature of the sport. This comeback is often cited as one of the greatest in Super Bowl history, emphasizing the importance of perseverance and tactical adjustments in football.
12. Super Bowl LVI: Los Angeles 23, Cincinnati 20
The Rams were favored, but the Bengals put up a fierce fight. Leading 20-16 late, Cincinnati couldn’t hold off Matthew Stafford and Cooper Kupp’s game-winning drive. The Bengals’ last-ditch effort was stymied by Aaron Donald, securing the Rams' victory. The clash between the high-flying Rams and the underdog Bengals provided plenty of drama, with key plays by stars on both sides.
Stafford’s determination and Kupp’s reliable hands were pivotal, while Donald’s defensive prowess sealed the deal, creating a memorable finale. The Bengals' remarkable run to the Super Bowl and their spirited performance against the Rams added to the game's excitement, leaving fans with a thrilling end to the NFL season. This game highlighted the unpredictability of the Super Bowl and the crucial role of key players in determining the outcome.
11. Super Bowl LI: New England 34, Atlanta 28
Considered by many the greatest Super Bowl, the Patriots' comeback from a 28-3 deficit was legendary. Tom Brady’s flawless execution forced overtime, and once New England won the coin toss, the outcome felt inevitable. James White’s touchdown run completed the largest comeback in Super Bowl history. This game highlighted Brady’s unparalleled ability to perform under pressure and the Patriots’ never-say-die attitude.
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/53104417/usa_today_9862323.0.jpg)
Atlanta’s collapse was dramatic, but it underscored the relentless nature of New England’s pursuit of victory. The game exemplified the highs and lows of football, with the Falcons' early dominance giving way to the Patriots' historic comeback, making it a classic for the ages. The combination of strategic brilliance and sheer determination by the Patriots showcased why they have been one of the most successful teams in NFL history.
10. Super Bowl LVII: Kansas City 38, Philadelphia 35
The Chiefs’ second consecutive Super Bowl win featured a resilient Patrick Mahomes leading a comeback. Despite trailing most of the game, Mahomes’ brilliance and a last-second Harrison Butker field goal sealed the victory, showcasing Kansas City’s relentless spirit. The duel between two potent offenses and the strategic maneuvers by both teams kept viewers enthralled.
Mahomes' poise and the Chiefs' ability to thrive in clutch moments highlighted their championship mettle and left fans buzzing. The Eagles' formidable performance and the back-and-forth nature of the game added layers of excitement, ensuring this Super Bowl would be remembered for its thrilling and unpredictable moments. This game further solidified Mahomes' reputation as a clutch performer and a rising star in the NFL.
9. Super Bowl XXIII: San Francisco 20, Cincinnati 16
Joe Montana’s coolness under pressure was on full display as he led a 92-yard game-winning drive. Cincinnati’s defense held strong until the final moments, but Montana’s pinpoint accuracy and calm demeanor secured another Super Bowl win for the 49ers. This game exemplified Montana’s legendary status and his ability to deliver in critical situations.
The Bengals’ valiant effort and strategic defense added to the suspense, making Montana’s last-minute heroics even more spectacular. The tension and excitement of the final drive highlighted why Montana is often referred to as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. His leadership and precision in the clutch moments underscored his legacy and the 49ers' dominance during that era.
8. Super Bowl XXXVIII: New England 32, Carolina 29
A tight game turned chaotic in the fourth quarter, with 37 combined points. Tom Brady’s late drive set up Adam Vinatieri’s game-winning field goal, giving the Patriots their second title in three years and solidifying Brady’s clutch reputation. The back-and-forth scoring and high stakes kept fans on the edge of their seats.
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/10114563/145497023.jpg.jpg)
Carolina’s spirited performance and New England’s strategic precision made this contest a classic, showcasing the unpredictable nature of football and the importance of every play. The dramatic swings in momentum and the thrilling conclusion left a lasting impression on viewers. Vinatieri’s reliable kicking and Brady’s calm under pressure defined this game as a thrilling and memorable chapter in Super Bowl history.
7. Super Bowl LII: Philadelphia 41, New England 33
Nick Foles out dueling Tom Brady was unexpected, but Foles’ performance and the iconic “Philly Special” play made this game unforgettable. The high-scoring affair ended with a defensive stop, preventing another Brady comeback and giving the Eagles their first Super Bowl win. The underdog narrative and Foles’ fearless play provided an inspiring storyline.
Philadelphia’s innovative plays and resilient defense against Brady’s onslaught captured the spirit of the city and the essence of an unforgettable Super Bowl. The game was a testament to the Eagles’ determination and the unpredictable nature of the NFL. Foles' performance, earning him Super Bowl MVP, remains one of the most remarkable underdog stories in Super Bowl history.
6. Super Bowl XLIII: Pittsburgh 27, Arizona 23
Arizona’s late-game heroics, including a Larry Fitzgerald touchdown, gave them a 23-20 lead. Ben Roethlisberger’s precise pass to Santonio Holmes in the final seconds secured a dramatic victory and the Steelers’ sixth Super Bowl title. The contrasting styles of both teams and the thrilling conclusion highlighted the unpredictability of the sport.
Holmes’ incredible catch and Roethlisberger’s determination underlined the game’s intensity, making it one of the most memorable Super Bowls. The Cardinals’ near-comeback and the Steelers’ resilience provided a thrilling spectacle that showcased the drama of football. This game is often remembered for its dramatic final drive and the outstanding individual performances that defined the outcome.
5. Super Bowl XLIX: New England 28, Seattle 24
A game defined by its thrilling conclusion, Tom Brady’s late-game magic and Malcolm Butler’s goal-line interception prevented Seattle from clenching back-to-back titles. The decision to pass instead of handing off to Marshawn Lynch remains one of the most debated play calls in Super Bowl history. The dramatic shift in momentum and the critical interception showcased the razor-thin margins between victory and defeat.
Brady’s poise and Butler’s heroics are etched in Super Bowl lore, exemplifying the game’s capacity for high drama. Seattle’s heartbreaking loss and New England’s triumphant comeback underscored the emotional highs and lows inherent in the sport. The controversial play call and Butler's remarkable interception are still discussed and analyzed, highlighting the game's lasting impact on NFL history.
4. Super Bowl XLII: New York Giants 17, New England 14
The Patriots’ quest for a perfect season was thwarted by Eli Manning and David Tyree’s miraculous helmet catch. The Giants’ defensive pressure kept Tom Brady in check, and Manning’s game-winning drive remains one of the biggest upsets in Super Bowl history. The Giants’ relentless defense and their ability to capitalize on crucial moments highlighted the unpredictability of the game.
Tyree’s catch remains one of the most iconic plays, symbolizing the improbable nature of New York’s victory and the excitement of the Super Bowl. The game’s dramatic conclusion and the Giants’ underdog triumph made it an instant classic. Manning's performance and the Giants' defensive strategies were critical in overcoming the highly favored Patriots, adding to the lore of this memorable Super Bowl.
3. Super Bowl XXXVI: New England 20, St. Louis 17
The Patriots were underdogs against the “Greatest Show on Turf.” Tom Brady’s final drive, capped by Adam Vinatieri’s game-winning field goal, began New England’s dynasty and showcased Brady’s clutch gene in his first Super Bowl appearance. The stark contrast between the high-powered Rams and the disciplined Patriots added to the intrigue.
Brady’s emergence as a future legend and the Patriots’ strategic brilliance set the stage for their dynasty, making this game a turning point in NFL history. The thrilling finish and the Patriots' unexpected victory highlighted the dramatic possibilities of the Super Bowl. This game marked the beginning of an era of dominance for New England, with Brady and Vinatieri's heroics becoming central to their legacy.
2. Super Bowl XXXIV: St. Louis 23, Tennessee 16
A lackluster first three quarters gave way to an explosive fourth. Kurt Warner’s touchdown pass to Isaac Bruce and the Titans’ last-second drive ending just shy of the goal line made for an unforgettable finish, with Mike Jones’ tackle securing the Rams’ victory. The dramatic conclusion and Warner’s heroics underscored the game’s intensity.
The Titans’ near-comeback and the Rams’ last-second defense provided a thrilling spectacle, encapsulating the essence of Super Bowl drama. The memorable last play, often referred to as "The Tackle," remains one of the most iconic moments in Super Bowl history. Warner’s MVP performance and the thrilling end cemented this game as one of the most exciting finishes ever seen on the biggest stage in football.
1. Super Bowl XXV: New York Giants 20, Buffalo 19
A tactical battle between Bill Parcells’ Giants and the high-powered Bills offense, this game culminated in Scott Norwood’s infamous missed field goal. The Giants’ ball-control strategy and Buffalo’s near-comeback created an enduring classic. The tension and strategic depth of the game, combined with the dramatic conclusion, exemplified the high stakes of the Super Bowl.
Norwood’s miss became one of the most memorable moments, symbolizing the fine line between triumph and heartbreak in sports. The Giants’ meticulous game plan and the Bills’ explosive offense provided a captivating contrast that kept fans enthralled until the final second. This game’s legacy lives on, as it demonstrated the impact of strategic planning and execution under pressure, making it a timeless classic in Super Bowl history.
These 15 Super Bowls have provided some of the most thrilling moments in sports history, showcasing the drama, skill, and unpredictability that make the NFL’s championship game a must-watch event year after year. Each game has etched its place in history, offering fans unforgettable memories and defining the legacy of the Super Bowl as the ultimate spectacle in football.